In this paper, we provide a detailed analysis and comparison of methods used to identify and retrieve feedback in analog electronic technology courses. These include positive and negative feedback, voltage and current feedback, as well as series and parallel feedback. Feedback is a fundamental concept in electronics with broad applications. It plays a crucial role in enhancing circuit performance by adjusting the output (voltage or current) to influence the input, thereby maintaining stability and achieving desired functionality.
However, students often find it challenging to understand these concepts, especially when dealing with complex circuits that may contain multiple types of feedback. This article aims to address this difficulty by explaining how to effectively distinguish between different types of feedback.
1. **How to Identify Feedback**
To determine if a circuit has feedback, one should look for a connection between the input and output loops. If such a component exists, like a resistor or capacitor, it indicates the presence of feedback. For example, in the circuit shown in Figure 1, the resistor Re is present in both the input and output loops, making it a feedback element.
2. **Distinguishing Positive and Negative Feedback**
The first step is to analyze the instantaneous polarity of the feedback signal. In common-emitter configurations, the collector and base are out of phase, while in common-base and common-collector circuits, the collector and emitter or base and emitter are in phase. For operational amplifier circuits, the inverting and non-inverting inputs have opposite and same polarities with respect to the output, respectively. By comparing the polarity of the feedback signal with the input, one can determine whether the feedback is positive or negative.
3. **Identifying Voltage Feedback and Current Feedback**
Voltage feedback occurs when the feedback signal is proportional to the output voltage, while current feedback is when it's proportional to the output current. A practical method to differentiate them is by short-circuiting the output. If the feedback disappears, it’s voltage feedback; if it remains, it’s current feedback. Additionally, the sampling point at the output helps: if the feedback is taken from the output voltage, it's voltage feedback; if from the current, it's current feedback.
4. **Discriminating Series Feedback and Parallel Feedback**
Series and parallel feedback differ based on how the feedback signal interacts with the input. If the feedback is compared as a voltage, it's series feedback; if as a current, it's parallel feedback. The location of the input and feedback signals also matters—introducing them from the same point typically results in parallel feedback, while different points indicate series feedback.
In summary, identifying feedback involves several steps: using the instantaneous polarity method to determine positive or negative feedback, analyzing the type of output signal (voltage or current), and examining how the feedback interacts with the input (series or parallel). Understanding these distinctions is essential for mastering analog electronics.
Guangzhou Yunge Tianhong Electronic Technology Co., Ltd , http://www.e-cigaretteyfactory.com